Casemiro vs James Garner
Casemiro, a 34-year-old defensive midfielder for Manchester United, and James Garner, a 25-year-old defensive midfielder for Everton, compared over the 2025/2026 season in the Premier League. Casemiro made 34 appearances and James Garner 38. The 8 metrics below are measured per 90 minutes, with percentages shown as season averages, and each player ranked against players in the same position in their own league.
Casemiro2025/2026 · Manchester United · Premier League · defensive midfielder · age 34
James Garner2025/2026 · Everton · Premier League · defensive midfielder · age 25per 90 · rank vs same position in leagueCasemiro leads on duels won at 6.54 per 90 against 5.51, 19% more (57th of 471 in the league) and passes at 55.6 per 90 against 47.3, 18% more (68th of 475 in the league).
James Garner leads on assists at 0.18 per 90 against 0.07, 165% more (63rd of 284 in the league), successful dribbles at 0.47 per 90 against 0.21, 128% more (237th of 418 in the league) and chances created at 1.40 per 90 against 1.15, 22% more (73rd of 426 in the league).
Overall James Garner has a clear edge, leading 6 of the 8 metrics to Casemiro's 2. Different roles inflate different columns, so read the ranks alongside the raw rates.
- Casemiro vs Elliot Anderson
- Ethan Ampadu vs Casemiro
- Casemiro vs Martín Zubimendi
- Casemiro vs Ryan Gravenberch
- Sander Berge vs Casemiro
- Elliot Anderson vs James Garner
- Ethan Ampadu vs James Garner
- Martín Zubimendi vs James Garner
- James Garner vs Ryan Gravenberch
- Sander Berge vs James Garner
- James Garner vs Moisés Caicedo