Sandro Tonali vs James Garner
Sandro Tonali, a 26-year-old defensive midfielder for Newcastle United, and James Garner, a 25-year-old defensive midfielder for Everton, compared over the 2025/2026 season in the Premier League. Sandro Tonali made 35 appearances and James Garner 38. The 8 metrics below are measured per 90 minutes, with percentages shown as season averages, and each player ranked against players in the same position in their own league.
Sandro Tonali2025/2026 · Newcastle United · Premier League · defensive midfielder · age 26
James Garner2025/2026 · Everton · Premier League · defensive midfielder · age 25per 90 · rank vs same position in leagueSandro Tonali leads on successful dribbles at 0.67 per 90 against 0.47, 41% more (198th of 432 in the league), passes at 55.2 per 90 against 47.3, 17% more (86th of 531 in the league) and ball recovery at 5.19 per 90 against 4.88, 7% more (112th of 516 in the league).
James Garner leads on assists at 0.18 per 90 against 0.07, 161% more (65th of 286 in the league), chances created at 1.40 per 90 against 0.92, 52% more (83rd of 440 in the league) and duels won at 5.51 per 90 against 3.78, 46% more (173rd of 511 in the league).
Overall James Garner has the better numbers, leading 5 of the 8 metrics to Sandro Tonali's 3. Different roles inflate different columns, so read the ranks alongside the raw rates.